Is it Better to File a Claim or Talk to a Lawyer First?
- Home / Personal Injury /
- Is it Better to File a Claim or Talk to a Lawyer First?
May 17, 2021
Accident victims often feel a sense of urgency to recover compensation from the at-fault party’s insurance company. An injury can cause tremendous financial strain as medical bills pile up, especially if you are unable to work.
Even if you plan to hire an attorney, you may think there is no harm in getting things started by filing a claim. However, it is important to be cautious when talking to the insurance company, even when doing something as simple as filing a claim. Insurance company representatives know how to make accident victims feel comfortable, which may result in victims saying things that hurt their credibility or the value of their claims.
Below, learn more about the pros and cons of filing a claim before talking to a lawyer. If you have questions about what to do after an accident, give Phillips Law Group a call. Our Phoenix-based personal injury lawyers are prepared to help you with each step of the legal process, including dealing with the insurance company.
The initial consultation is free. Call 1-800-706-3000 today.
Talking to the Insurance Company After an Accident
Many times, insurance companies contact victims while they are still recovering and before they have had a chance to call an attorney. However, you can decide not to take the call and tell the insurance company you will call them back later. You can also tell them you need to talk to an attorney first and the attorney will contact them.
Despite what the insurance company may say, talking to your attorney first will not ruin your chances of recovering compensation. You are within your rights to delay this initial conversation for a little bit.
If you choose to talk to the insurance company first, it is important to be careful with what you say. All they need to know is you were in an accident and suffered injuries for which you are seeking treatment. You can tell them the date, time and location of the crash and if you contacted the police.
Beyond that, you do not need to say much. The insurance company may ask how bad your injuries are or for more details about the crash. However, it is often a bad idea to start discussing these things with an insurance representative before speaking with an attorney. You could unknowingly say something that hurts your claim.
For example, crash victims often feel sorry for being in an accident and may say so. They may think they bear some fault for what happened, even if the accident was entirely the fault of the other driver. Insurance companies know this, and they know what to say and what questions to ask to encourage victims to say things that sound like an admission of fault.
The insurance company may also ask you to gauge how severe your injuries are. This is a bad idea because there is no way an accident victim can know how bad his or her injuries are. Even doctors may not know initially, because they may need to see how you respond to treatment and may also need to see test results.
Benefits of Talking to a Lawyer First
When comparing injury attorneys to insurance companies, it is important to recognize that your lawyer’s best interests are the same as your best interests. The insurance company’s interests, however, conflict with yours.
The insurance company, as a for-profit business, is committed to making money and therefore pays out as little as possible to accident victims. An injury attorney is focused on recovering as much compensation for the client as possible. If you do not get paid, he or she does not get paid.
If you call a lawyer before the insurance company, he or she can review your situation to determine if you may have a valid case. He or she can also answer your questions, and there is no risk of you saying something that may hurt your claim.
For example, if you think you may be at fault, an experienced lawyer can give his or her perspective and this conversation is confidential. That means the insurance company will not find out about it. If you discuss this issue with the insurance company, they will probably agree that you are at fault and reduce the value of your claim. They may even use this conversation as a basis for denying your claim.
A lawyer can also explain what you can do to help strengthen your claim. For example, if you have not yet been to the doctor, an attorney will likely tell you to get to one right away. He or she is also likely to tell you to follow the doctor’s orders. For example, if the doctor tells you not to work, you should stay home.
A lawyer can review evidence you have already collected to determine if you may have a valid case. For example, pictures from the scene, medical records, interviews with witnesses and the police report can all help an attorney assess whether your injuries may have been caused by negligence.
If you talked to the insurance company briefly and they made a settlement offer, your attorney can give his or her perspective on whether the offer is fair. It is very difficult to assess whether a settlement offer is fair on your own, but an experienced attorney has done this many times.
Need Help After an Accident? Call Phillips Law Group
An initial consultation with a licensed attorney from our firm is free of charge and there is no obligation to take legal action. Contacting our firm to discuss your accident comes with no risk. There are also no fees while working on your case, and our lawyers are not paid unless they recover compensation.
Whether you have already contacted the insurance company or not, we may be able to assist you. Our attorneys have recovered more than $1 billion on behalf of our clients.
Phillips Law Group. No Upfront Fees. Ph: 1-800-706-3000
Free Case Evaluation
By submitting your contact information, you agree that we may contact you by telephone (including text) and email in accordance with our Terms and Privacy Policy

Your message has been sent
Thank you for your message, we will get back to you soon.
Categories:
- Auto Accidents
- Business Litigation
- Class Action Lawsuits
- Defective Drug
- Defective Products
- Employee Rights
- Employment Law
- Firm News
- Local
- Medical Malpractice
- Motorcycle Accidents
- Nursing Home Abuse
- Pedestrian Accident
- Personal Injury
- Premises Liability
- Product Liability
- Slip and Fall
- Social Security Disability
- Workers' Compensation
- Wrongful Death
-
Phillips Law Group has a proven track record of success. Juan Roque, in particular, is integral to that. He works with integrity, compassion, and an undefeated optimism that makes him a valuable asset.
-
Liz was great
-
Working at Phillips Law Group has been great the 1st few years in I noticed how well organized and run this Firm was from Intake to Settlement the Client has the expertise of a staff member uniquely qualified for the particular stage of each Clients claim and all other Law firms try to emulate what we do here but none quite get it right because they lack one major component “Compassion”. We are a FAMILY not just a group of people/employees. We care deeply about each other and our clients’ we are considerate, compassionate and make sure that all our Clients’ needs are met from beginning to end. That’s because we treat our clients just like we treat each other. Nothing like walking through the office and saying Hello to fellow employees who always seem to be smiling. 16yrs in and it only seems to be getting better.
-
Two family members were in a bad wreck a couple of years ago, and as a result called Phillips Law to represent them. Montana Thompson was the attorney assigned to the case with the help of Nemo Farr as legal assistant. Mr. Thompson litigated a very generous settlement for both my stepdaughter and her son. Because my grandson is a minor, I decided to act as conservator for him to ensure the settlement was safe and secure. Montana helped with that process, but it was Nemo who went way above and beyond the call in finding a financial institution to use for the restricted account. There were some glitches in that process but Nemo helped navigate them with a calm expertise which belies his age. I would consider them both great representatives of the level of commitment to their clients and assets to their firm.
-
I enjoy my work day here at Phillips Law Group and generally speaking I love my clients. Every day brings a new client or task to keep me on my toes. Administration keeps open communication and is hilarious most of the time! I love the way we celebrate FRIDAY, holidays and birthdays and how everything is so competitive. All in all I’m so fortunate to be here and I enjoy what I do.
-
I was recently served court documents that I was being sued from an accident that happened years ago. For someone who has never been through something like this and not familiar with the court lingo or where to even begin, it was very frustrating and stressful. I reached out to a family member who knew Tracy Laskos and the great reputation of Phillips Law Group and within the hours of the initial call for help, I had a direct number to Lead Attorney Nassar. Nassar heard my case and almost instantly put me at ease by explaining the process and how easy it was to handle. Nassar spoke to me like he was a friend, not like I was a client. I am so grateful to Tracy, Nasar and of course my cousin Stephanie for helping out and giving me the direction that I needed to get through this situation. I plan on referring my friends, family and patients that are in need of a personal injury Attorney to Phillips Law Group. Thank you!!
-
I want to thank attorneys Tim and Robert and the paralegal Bethany for all they had done on my case. They were all empathetic, knowledgeable and professional. All my questions were answered, emails returned in a timely matter, and promises fulfilled. I recommend Phillips Law Group if you need help with your injury case.
-
Jasmine , did a great job . Highly recommend!!!!!
-
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value As someone who is familiar with the inner workings of the auto insurance industry I can whole heartedly endorse Steven J. Jones and Phillips law group as someone I would want on my side should litigation take place. They handled my case professionally, honestly, and with satisfactory results which I would not have expected without enlisting their help.
-